• Mon, 19 Nov

Very little Thuggee in Thugs of Hindostan 2

This is the kind of film that could drive Amitabh Bachchan into retirement, writes Deepa Gahlot

Review and Comments

Deepa Gahlot

Deepa Gahlot08 Nov 2018

Thugs of Hindostan

Directed by Vijay Krishna Acharya

Cast: Amitabh Bachchan, Aamir Khan, Fatima Sana Shaikh, Lloyd Owen, Katrina Kaif and others

Rating: Two stars


Talk of waking up after the ship has sailed. Hollywood is tiring of the Pirates Of The Caribbean franchise (which went on for far too long, considering its origins as an amusement park ride), and a filmmaker in Mumbai suddenly gets inspired. Vijay Krishna Acharya’s Thugs Of Hindostan gets Aamir Khan to play a Jack Sparrow type and hopes the rest will fall into place.

It’s not as though one expects historical or geographical authenticity from a commercial Bollywood film, but some accuracy would have helped. First of all, in a film with Thugs in the title, there is very little Thuggee. There is a band of merry men and some women under Khudabaksh Jahaazi aka Azaad,  (Amitabh Bachchan), who want independence from British rule, but they are not Thugs.

The film opens in 1795, when the stone-faced devils from the British East India company kill rajas and steal kingdoms. One such is snatched from Zafira’s (Fatia Sana Shaikh) family, and she is saved by Azaad so that he can teach her how to use a bow and arrow. Eleven years later, a crook who calls himself Firangi Mallah (Aamir Khan) rides in on a donkey and gives the red-uniformed tax collectors in the employ of the Brits a tough time.

But he is a kind of double agent, who collects from both sides, so when John Clive (Lloyd Owen) wants him to spy on Azaad, he plays one against the other, with his quick thinking and glib tongue. He also acquires a sidekick (Mohammad Zeeshan Ayyub) who serves no useful purpose, and between intrigues, gets the time to shake a leg with a sexy dancer Suraiya (Katrina Kaif), who wears very tiny costumes and does some Sheela Ki Jawaani kind of moves when they were not even invented.

Firangi, who wears a lot of jewellery and a top hat, wins the heart of Azaad, and they do a lot of buddy stuff, but the Brits keep interrupting. They are the kind of caricature ‘gora’ fools who speak to each other in Hindi, seat a scruffy spy at the head of a table and watch him eat, and celebrate Dussehra with the natives. Pity, no cricket!

There is a lot of storming of ships, swinging on vines, sword fights and shootouts, but not a minute of excitement or an iota of thrills, as characters dressed in grungy chic costumes, odd headgear and tattoos, rush about looking for a lost plot with loud background music. Only Aamir Khan, with his twinkling eyes and dazzling smile, looks like he is having fun—at least he gets some witty lines.  This is the kind of film that could drive Amitabh Bachchan into retirement! 

Oh, and btw, was the hawk that glides around the rebel camp, picked from Guru Dutt’s pirate adventure Baaz (1953)? Sixty-five years ago, they could swagger and swashbuckle better than these folk with a huge budget and expensive CGI at their disposal.

Hindi Films

Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra, India

Related Places you may like

  • Mohalla Assi: Boring & Futile

    Chandraprakash Dwivedi resorts to the lazy and ineffective shortcut of characters rattling off pages of dialogue, writes Deepa Gahlot

    Venue : Hindi Films

  • Jack and Dil: Just Hot Air

    Jack And Dil is a doable romcom, but with an indifferent script, uninspired performances, forgettable music, writes Deepa Gahlot

    Venue : Hindi Films

  • Lupt: Horror film?

    Like the road in the film, Lupt goes nowhere, writes Deepa Gahlot

    Venue : Hindi Films

  • Kaashi In Search Of Ganga: Strange & Slapdash

    Kaashi In Search Of Ganga is a film desperately in search of style, sense and substance, writes Deepa Gahlot

    Venue : Hindi Films

  • Baazaar is a watery mess!

    The lesson to be learnt: don’t mess with a classic, writes Deepa Gahlot

    Venue : Hindi Films

Share This





Popular Destinations

Hindi Films

Teacher’s Way

Teacher’s Way: 12 must-see Hindi movies in which teachers play the protagonist

Hindi Films


Sriram Raghavan is in his element here, as he is with pulp thrillers that do not bother much about morality or redemption, writes Deepa Gahlot

Hindi Films

Very watchable horror film!

Tumbbad creates an entirely original horror movie that has a lot more to it than the usual schlock, writes Deepa Gahlot

Hindi Films

Neither comedy, nor high drama, but brilliant little moments

Gajraj Rao gives one of the finest performances of the year, writes Deepa Gahlot

Hindi Films


Stree could have been a real woman power film, peppered with ghost-busting wit, pity it falls short, writes Deepa Gahlot


Copyright © 2018 Xyngr.com. All Rights Reserved